YKS and YKK look similar, but they cool differently

YKS and YKK are both totally enclosed high-voltage squirrel-cage motors in the same frame range (H355-630, 185-5000 kW). The real difference is how heat leaves the motor: YKS uses a water-air cooler (ICW81A), while YKK uses a top-mounted air-air cooler (IC611). Choose the wrong one and you either pay for cooling water you do not need, or end up with a motor too large for the floor space and airflow you actually have.

Quick comparison table

ItemY Series (open)YKK (air-air)YKS (water-air)
Cooling methodIC01 open self-ventilatedIC611 air-air coolerICW81A water-air cooler
EnclosureIP23 openIP44/IP54 enclosedIP44/IP54 enclosed
Frame rangeH355-630H355-630H355-630
Voltage6 / 10 kV3 / 6 / 10 kV6 / 10 kV
Output185-5000 kW185-5000 kW185-5000 kW
Cooling mediumClean ambient airAmbient air onlyClean cooling water
Typical siteClean indoor plantsDusty or harsh plantsPlants with water and compact area

How each cooling method works

Y series is an open IC01 motor: outside air flows straight through the windings and out, so it is the cheapest and lightest, but the air has to be clean. YKK is a closed box-frame motor with an air-air cooler mounted on top: internal air is blown through the cooler, and ambient air passes through the cooler to carry the heat away. Nothing from outside enters the motor, so dust and humidity stay out. YKS is identical in construction to YKK except the top cooler is water-cooled instead of air-cooled: a water-air heat exchanger removes more heat from a smaller package.

How to choose: YKS or YKK

  • Choose Y (open) when the motor is indoors in a clean room with good ventilation. Lowest cost, smallest and lightest, but the surrounding air must be dust-free.
  • Choose YKK (air-air) when the area is dusty, humid, or has no reliable cooling water. Self-contained, needs only free airflow around the motor, and is easy to install and run.
  • Choose YKS (water-air) when floor space is tight, heat load is high, or you already have a cooling-water loop or cooling tower. Higher cooling efficiency and usually quieter, at the cost of a water system.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between YKS and YKK?

Both are enclosed high-voltage squirrel-cage motors. The difference is the cooler: YKS is water-air cooled (ICW81A), YKK is air-air cooled (IC611).

Which type is cheaper to install?

YKS usually needs a cooling-water circuit or cooling tower, so total system cost can be higher. YKK is self-contained and only needs airflow around it, so installation and running cost are simpler.

Can YKK be used in dusty or harsh environments?

Yes. YKK is a totally enclosed box-frame motor with IP44/IP54 protection, so dust and humidity are kept out. It suits cement, mining, steel and other dusty sites.

Does YKS require cooling water?

Yes. YKS must be connected to clean cooling water, or a closed water loop with a cooling tower. Water quality, flow and temperature must be designed in.

Which is quieter, YKS or YKK?

The water-air cooler is more compact and damps noise better, so YKS is generally quieter and takes less floor space at the same rating.

Can YKS and YKK share the same mounting dimensions?

No. Frame and mounting dimensions differ between the two designs. Always check the outline and installation drawing for the exact frame (H355-630) and mounting before you order.